A pair of human rights groups are challenging the UK government’s shockingly intrusive order for Apple to create a backdoor into its encrypted user data, as first reported by Financial Times. Privacy International and Liberty have filed a legal complaint with the country’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal (IPT), which is reportedly scheduled to hear Apple’s appeal on Friday.
The complaint argues that Apple’s appeal to the order should be publicly heard. In addition, the groups’ challenge contends that the government’s move violates customers’ free expression and privacy rights by forcing the company to neuter its product security.
“The UK’s use of a secret order to undermine security for people worldwide is unacceptable and disproportionate,” Caroline Wilson Palow, legal director at Privacy International, told The FT. “People the world over rely on end-to-end encryption to protect themselves from harassment and oppression. No country should have the power to undermine that protection for everyone.”
UK media outlets (including the BBC, Reuters, Financial Times, The Guardian and more) have also filed complaints with the IPT, arguing that the case should be heard publicly. Ditto for the advocacy organizations Big Brother Watch, Index on Censorship and the Open Rights Group.
The UK order requires Apple to give the government blanket access to private user data encrypted through its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature. Introduced in iOS 16.2 in 2022, ADP applies end-to-end encryption to iCloud data like device backups, Messages content, notes and photos. Even Apple can’t access it.
Apple removed ADP in the UK in response to the order before issuing its own legal challenge. But since the backdoor would also apply to users outside the UK, the private data of anyone with an Apple account would be vulnerable. Security experts (and common sense) warn that the backdoor would needlessly expose anyone with an Apple Account to foreign spying, hackers and adversarial countries.
We only know about the UK order because of a leak last month. That’s because it was issued under the country’s Investigatory Powers Act 2016, which expanded the surveillance powers of British intelligence agencies and law enforcement (earning its, uh, term of endearment, the “Snooper’s Charter”). The rules also prevent Apple from commenting on or publicly acknowledging the existence of the privacy-eviscerating order — or using its appeal to delay compliance. Apple said last month, “We have never built a back door or master key to any of our products or services, and we never will.”
Trending Products

AULA Keyboard, T102 104 Keys Gaming Keyboard and Mouse Combo with RGB Backlit Quiet Laptop Keyboard, All-Steel Panel, Waterproof Gentle Up PC Keyboard, USB Wired Keyboard for MAC Xbox PC Players

Acer Aspire 3 A315-24P-R7VH Slim Laptop computer | 15.6″ Full HD IPS Show | AMD Ryzen 3 7320U Quad-Core Processor | AMD Radeon Graphics | 8GB LPDDR5 | 128GB NVMe SSD | Wi-Fi 6 | Home windows 11 Residence in S Mode

MATX PC Case, 6 ARGB Followers Pre-Put in, Sort-C Gaming PC Case, 360mm Radiator Help, Tempered Glass Entrance & Facet Panels, Mid Tower Black Micro ATX Laptop Case

Wireless Keyboard and Mouse Combo, Lovaky 2.4G Full-Sized Ergonomic Keyboard Mouse, 3 DPI Adjustable Cordless USB Keyboard and Mouse, Quiet Click for Computer/Laptop/Windows/Mac (1 Pack, Black)

Lenovo Newest 15.6″ Laptop, Intel Pentium 4-core Processor, 15.6″ FHD Anti-Glare Display, Ethernet Port, HDMI, USB-C, WiFi & Bluetooth, Webcam (Windows 11 Home, 40GB RAM | 1TB SSD)

ASUS RT-AX5400 Twin Band WiFi 6 Extendable Router, Lifetime Web Safety Included, Immediate Guard, Superior Parental Controls, Constructed-in VPN, AiMesh Appropriate, Gaming & Streaming, Sensible Dwelling

AOC 22B2HM2 22″ Full HD (1920 x 1080) 100Hz LED Monitor, Adaptive Sync, VGA x1, HDMI x1, Flicker-Free, Low Blue Mild, HDR Prepared, VESA, Tilt Modify, Earphone Out, Eco-Pleasant

Logitech MK540 Superior Wi-fi Keyboard and Mouse Combo for Home windows, 2.4 GHz Unifying USB-Receiver, Multimedia Hotkeys, 3-12 months Battery Life, for PC, Laptop computer
